Skip to content 
When Emma was a baby, Richard, the former finance executive, had insisted on opening an investment account. He spoke of compound interest and diversified portfolios with the assurance of a prophet. Caleb trusted him. I trusted Caleb. For twelve years, every birthday, every Christmas, instead of toys, Richard and Diane would give us a card informing us that a deposit had been made for her future. We never asked any questions. We were grateful.
Diane tried to laugh, but a high-pitched, muffled hiccup escaped her. “This isn’t the time to talk about money, Caleb. We’re eating.”
“I asked you for the updated statements last month,” Caleb continued, completely ignoring her. “You said you were waiting for some documents. Then you said the bank had changed its online interface. Then you stopped answering my calls.” “
Richard’s face froze, his skin taking on the waxy pallor of a corpse. “The market has been volatile. There have been… adjustments. We can discuss this privately.”
“No,” Caleb said, and the word hung like a guillotine blade. “We can discuss it now.”
Emma slowly raised her eyes. She no longer looked frightened; she seemed confused. “Dad?”
Caleb didn’t look at her. He couldn’t. He was staring at his father with the intensity of a sniper. “How many are left?”
Diane picked up her glass of water. Her hand was shaking so badly that the water overflowed and stained the tablecloth. “Investments fluctuate, Caleb! You can’t panic every time they dip!”
Caleb took his phone out of his pocket. He tapped the screen and held it up. “I called the bank on Friday.” I finally managed to reach a manager who was willing to review the history. The account was closed eight months ago.
I felt my blood rush to my ears, a roar like the ocean. Closed?
“Richard?” I managed to say with difficulty.
Richard looked at Diane, and for the first time, I clearly understood the situation. There was no shock on their faces. It was calculated. They weren’t surprised the money had disappeared; they were surprised they’d been caught.
“The money has been reinvested,” Richard said, a hint of arrogance returning to his voice.
“Into what?” Caleb asked.
Silence. The grandfather clock in the hallway ticked loudly. Tick. Tock. Tick. Tock.
“We needed a short-term loan,” Richard finally murmured, looking at the centerpiece.
“For whom?”
“For Ava’s medical care,” Diane blurted out. “You know she had problems last year! The specialists, the tests…”
The words remained, seemingly unshakeable. Ava had been sick. Nothing serious, thankfully, but there had been a scare: migraines, fainting spells. We had sent her flowers. We had brought her home-cooked meals. We had offered to babysit. No one had ever mentioned money.
Caleb’s jaw tightened. “You took the money meant for our daughter’s education—money that we, and Ila’s parents, had contributed for ten years—without telling us?”
“It was temporary!” Richard exclaimed, slamming his fist on the table. “We were going to give it back! Family is about helping each other, Caleb! My God, you’ve become so selfish.”
“With what?” “What do you want me to put it in with?” Caleb asked, his voice icy calm.
Diane leaned forward, her eyes pleading. “We thought you’d understand. You always preferred Emma anyway. Ava has so little…”
“Stop it,” Caleb said. “Just stop.” He looked at his father. “How much, Dad? What was the final balance after the liquidation?”
Richard rubbed his forehead, shielding his eyes. He mumbled a number.
“I didn’t hear you,” Caleb said.
“$38,000,” Richard whispered.
It felt like a punch to the gut. Thirty-eight thousand dollars. This wasn’t just money for my birthday. This was Caleb’s annual bonuses. This was my grandmother’s inheritance. This was twelve years of missed vacations and secondhand clothes.
“Does that mean I won’t be going to university?” Emma asked. Her voice was so faint I could barely hear it, but it broke my heart.